It is expected given the design of handgun rounds. To save on time, you can buy factory loaded ones in which the .44 Mag will cost much more than the .357 Mag. The velocity will also tell the probability of the penetration of the bullet after shooting. If you want to spend less, then do load the ammo yourself. It was initially developed to be a more potent load of the .44 S&W Special, its parent cartridge, by Elmer Keith in 1955.. Made largely popular by Clint Eastwood in his 1971 movie “Dirty Harry”, it has enjoyed a well-deserved reputation among law enforcers, hunters and sporting arms enthusiasts. So, let’s take a look at our eight rounds and see how the sectional densities of the bullets match up. The same goes for the brass when loading by hand. This damage is very important when it comes to a person who is using the handgun for self-defense or hunting. The higher the ballistic coefficient, the better the bullet is at cutting through the wind with minimal air drag and less prone to wind drift. The only thing better than a 357 or 44 Magnum is a 45 Colt. We will take a look at the velocity, ballistic coefficients, and the trajectory of the 357 Mag versus the 44 Mag to better sort these two cartridges into specific shooting applications at the end of the article. Later, Remington, as well as Smith and Wesson, began to spread the cartridges commercially and they became a friend for the shooters and the hunters. If someone takes time to fire there shot, then they would get their predicted trajectory performance. Pes 2021 psp In the words of Gunblast writer Jeff Quinn Quote: " The 357 Magnum out of a carbine barrel is a whole different animal than the same cartridge fired from a four or six inch revolver. One of the common ways of calculating it is through a ballistics calculator in which the weight of the bullet, powder charge, the firearm weight, and the muzzle velocity are kept as factors. Recoil is also a factor that affects accuracy. What this number will tell you is how well a bullet is streamlined. So, now that we know a bit about both of them let us see the difference that they have in their performance. This is obvious when looking at 400 inches of bullet drop at these ranges. The 357 magnum can also shoot 38 specials. The .357 Magnum on the other hand does this job and that of a game getter as well. Where there is going to be a major difference between these two cartridges when discussing accuracy has to do with recoil. Sniper Country is reader-supported. What stands out is the large increase in recoil energy for the .44 Mag over the .357. 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum: In-depth Comparison - Outdoor Hunt Though it is important, putting numbers to accuracy for cartridge comparison is difficult to do. This doesn’t imply that the .357 Mag has poor penetration for handgun cartridge. The accuracy of the cartridges differs in terms of recoil. The .44 is a bit powerful for self defense, but the 44 magnum can also shoot the .44 special, which will be plenty adequete for defense. The higher grain weight of this round and the amount of velocity behind it bump it up to energy levels that are even higher than three of the .44 Mag rounds. Below, we have listed these rounds. The .357 is well suited for a defensive, as well as hunting firearm. Between rounds, perhaps, but we don’t feel comfortable saying one cartridge is more accurate than the other. Both of these cartridges are known for their power and associated recoil. With a degree in Microbiology and several years of doctoral work manipulating bacterial genes, he attempts to merge the rational and unbiased thinking of scientific research with the passions of hunting and fishing. From this data, we see that there is not a huge and discernible difference between the ballistic coefficients when looking at cartridge vs cartridge. But he has yet to make up his mind on whether or not he should get one, because he’s already got a Glock 31. These differences are not very significant until you get out to the 75 and 100-yard mark. I enjoy shooting all three most common centerfire pistol calibers in lever guns: the 357 magnum, the 44 magnum, and the 45 Colt. By now, we have talked about the overall performance of the cartridges, both of which are quite popular among handgun users. Lets take a look at a few numbers first..44 special. Today, we’re looking at .357 Magnum and .44 Magnum when fired from lever action rifles (in this case, two identical rifles — a pair of Henry X Models). They are not the cheapest rounds on the market, but for their quality, we think they are more than a fair price. Both of them have originated in the USA and people have loved them for a while. On the flipside, if you are a .44 mag handgunner, then thats the obvious choice. Our pick for the top defense round for the .357 Mag is the Hornady FTX Critical Defense 125gr round. 44-40. The .44 Special with good handloads and the right bullet will drop a deer. The bullet is generally fired into a ballistic gel, which is said to mimic the human flesh or the target. We will take a brief look at the history of the two cartridges, compare performance specs using several rounds of each cartridge, and then wrap the article up discussing how their performance translates into using them in certain situations. When it comes to powerful revolver cartridges, two of the most popular, effective, and well-known options are the.357 Magnum and the.44 Magnum. So, the cartridge was developed by Elmer Keith, Phil Sharpe, along with Smith and Wesson, by performing changes on the .38 that was used back then. The .38 Special and .357 Magnum are both rimmed, centerfire cartridges commonly used in revolvers. There are better options for concealed weapons chambered for the .357 though they are often smaller with a shorter barrel which makes the recoil pretty vicious. Now, most factory loads for a handgun can be used in a carbine chambered for the same cartridge, but there are some rounds designed specifically for use in a carbine and are better suited for long-range shooting. It also depends on the round. doctorxring, Feb 4, 2011 #9. frankenstein406 Member. We do think that the .357 Mag will be better at handling successive shots for something that isn’t used to shooting through a handgun regularly. I was asked why someone would consider a .44 special over the .357 magnum for carry or general defense. The .44 Mag has a much more pronounced and severe recoil than the .357 Mag. It all has to do with the propellant. The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. So now that we have all of the ballistic and other performance comparisons down let’s think about the applications of the 357 Mag versus 44 Mag. 76Highboy Reloading. You're probably not using... Crossbows hunting can be a fun and rewarding activity. .357 Magnum – 9 × 32R mm nabój rewolwerowy opracowany w pierwszej połowie lat trzydziestych i produkowany od 1935 roku w firmie Smith & Wesson.Pierwszy typ amunicji określanej jako "Magnum". The trajectory of this round is the only downfall of this round once you hit the 75-yard mark, but up until then, it has a flat trajectory. You may never expect it at a distance of 500 yards, but we believe that a distance of 50 to 100 yards is a good measure. vs. 700 ft-lbs.). dxr. .357 Mag seems to be more common and cheaper than. Some articles are disingenuous as they compare the .350 Legend from a rifle platform to the .357 Magnum from a pistol. The data that we are using for our ammo comparisons comes from ballistic calculators as well as from the manufacturer of each round. As the neck is longer in the .44 Mag, it can hold bullets of heavier grain compared to the .357 Mag. It might skew more towards game defense rather than hunting because of the trajectory at ranges greater than 75 yards. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or It was also seen that when a heavier bullet is used with .357 Mag, it can transfer more power, which transforms into greater damage. Still, there are .44 Mag rounds that are as fast or faster than the .357 rounds out to the 50-yard mark, but you can expect some heavy recoil. Suicide Claimed More Lives in October Than 10 Months of COVID-19 in Japan, Report Shows - Foundation for Economic Education . In mark3smle test you can see the .357 penetration at 22 inches. The 20+ Best Kayaks of 2020 – Reviewed & Compared in... Top 10+ Best Layout Blinds – Reviews And Buying Guide 2020. So which of these two is better? True, the 44 magnum can also shoot 44 special, but there isn't nearly as much of a downgrade in kick and boom in the 44 as in the 357/38special. But the 357 magnum has something else going for it. In February of the following year, Elmer received a prototype of what would later become the S&W Model 29 and the first few runs of … The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .357 Magnum vs .454 Casull ammo rounds. If you want a faster velocity, you always have the option to choose smaller and lighter bullets. The longer barrel and lack of a cylinder gap that one gets with a .357 Magnum cartridge fired from a rifle ups the muzzle velocity. The energy is transferred into the target object and it causes the damage that is seen. But what about a good 170 grain SWC moving at 1,300 fps from the .357? Second, with just the criteria of .357 vs. .44 Special - the question is a bit of a non-starter. So, it is time that we saw the areas where the cartridges are used. Both of them have been popular among people who need it for self-defense, and we can see the reason. Developed in the 1950s by Elmer Keith, the .44 Magnum improved upon the power of the .357 Magnum. The .38 Special case length is roughly 1.15 inches, while .357 Magnum is 1.29 inches. For comparison and simplicity sake, we are not factoring in these variables into our comparison, but do keep that in mind. As we mentioned before, and is important enough to mention again, there is more to a cartridge’s effectiveness than the amount of ft.lb force it carries when talking about its ability to stop a target. For the .357 Mag, we like the .357 Mag Federal Personal Defense Jacketed Hollow Point 125gr. 1964 by Keith Davis, by partner and pistolsmith of the Bain & Davis Gunshop of San Gabriel, California. As we said, both the loads are quite popular among people who use their handgun for self-defense when accuracy is expected to be maximum. On the flipside, if you are a .44 mag … Wildlife photography is a thrilling activity but can sometimes be challenging. Stopping power can encompass several different factors. Not too shabby. doctorxring, Feb 4, 2011 #9. frankenstein406 Member. Both are also in rounds with a variety of bullet type options that offer rapid expansion for large wound formation. We will focus more on typical ranges handguns are used for shortly. To look at the ballistic and other performance characteristics, we have chosen five factory rounds for each cartridge that covers a range of bullet weights and designs. Though the .357 Mag rounds have a smaller diameter, the huge increase in weight of the .44 Mag rounds boost their sectional density. A bullet needs to travel well and have good penetration to be effective. The internet is the best place that helps you to consult about the choice. Both cartridge types have their pros and cons and excel at certain shooting applications. The .44 magnum loads were not unmanageable, but I didn't usually shoot more than about a dozen per range trip. Around this period, the US police force was in desperately looking for a cartridge with better terminal ballistics in self-defense or shooting/hunting scenarios. 44 compare accuracy, range, and recoil-wise? And for these cartridges, you are taking shots at close range. When thinking about home defense, both cartridges offer way more than enough stopping power for an intruder. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. It has been seen that a .44 Mag works better with a trail gun. You can also get .357 magnum energy from a 10mm semi-auto. Lv 6. As for bullet energy, the 357 comes out at 566 ft-lbs while the 44 creates 832 & 904 ft-lbs. This coefficient is derived after studying the variables of bullet dimensions and it helps in determining if the bullet is streamlined or not. So, the cartridge that you choose should also come with great accuracy. I have a Ruger GP100 in .357 and I had a S&W 629 in .44. This gives you much better-stopping power, and the soft point bullet gives a lot of expansion and wound creation. Along with that, there are different varieties when it comes to .357 Mag, which isn’t available for .44 Mag. Several lever-gun manufacturers make lever-action rifles and carbines in .41 Magnum, including Henry Repeating Arms. Choosing the right cartridge will often depend on the bullet that you want to use. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. 158 grains in the 357 conjured up an average velocity of 1363 fps and 651 foot-pounds of energy, while 240 grains in the 44 gave him 1270 fps and 859 foot-pounds. As the shots are close-ranged and the shooter can often be a novice, measuring efficiency can, at times, be challenging. And the rim is about 1.285’’ of length. And though the numbers might differ when being fired from your handgun, the differences between each round from both cartridges should remain constant. The higher the sectional density, the more force is applied to a smaller area which gives you better penetration. The .357 Magnum cartridges were made to be used by the police department as they needed a better terminal performing handgun load in the 1930s. As you can imagine, this is most likely going to result in pretty different ballistic and terminal performances between the two different cartridges which we will look at in detail shortly. 357 and. BONUS OFFER: Get your 500 Page Ammo Comparison Handbook (worth $43) for FREE right into your inbox. However, if the 357 magnum and the 44 magnum are BOTH in large frame guns, then the 357 magnum will kick less. For such a round to be effective, you are going to have to put some force behind them and what you get from that extra power is more recoil. The .357 Mag cartridges are nothing less; they also perform well. 2 1. eddygordo19. Price is always a factor when thinking about buying a firearm, especially if you are still on the fence about exactly what it is that you need. Because of this method, the comparisons should be valid, but as we mentioned earlier, the actual numbers could change depending on the firearm you are using. They'll both kill you if they hit you, but the .44 will make a bigger mess. So let’s take a look at the recoil energy that is generated from these cartridges. If you look at the .38 Special and the .357 Magnum, the only clear difference is the length. The style of the bullet is just as important, and that is your decision. The origins of the .44 Mag come from the .44 Special that was tinkered with by Elmer Keith to provide more velocity and energy to the heavy bullets used. The much heavier bullets for the .44mag give a lot more penetration than the lighter .357 bullets and the force carried by the bullets is much greater at further distances which also make it a better choice for hunting or protection from larger game. The .357 Magnum is a powerful cartridge, but in this case it takes a narrow 2nd place to the 10mm Auto. While a lot of these .44 Mag rounds carry more energy than the .357 Mag rounds, it doesn’t mean the .357 rounds cannot stop an intruder. We think that this will be great for shooters and hunters who are always looking for the best products to avoid misses. That is as far from the truth as you can get. Overall, a higher ballistic coefficient usually coincides with a bullet that is easier to put on target down range. Best Concealed Carry Insurance [Comparison Chart]. Though less than the .44 Mag, the .357 Mag rounds are still around the 500ft.lb mark at 50 yards, which is still enough to penetrate and cause damage to targets. The kinetic energy that is present on the bullet is an important part of its stopping power. The later one has a more voluminous cartridge, which helps store more gun powder, and it is also able to take better pressure after ignition. If you’re not well practiced with handling the heavy recoil, they can influence your shot, and they will influence your ability to make quick follow up shots that are accurate, especially when you are in a situation where you need to protect yourself, and the adrenaline is pumping. The largest of the .44 Mag bullets show the lowest velocities from the muzzle out to 50 yards which we would expect. Thanks Learn how your comment data is processed. 3. The .357 Magnum today is a favorite of handgun connoisseurs with its rich history, home defense with its excellent terminal ballistics, and hunters as well. The recoil that a person uses will often depend on the model of handgun that you are using. The .357 magnum is easier for more people to handle, and thus, gets used in more shootings, AND with better accuracy. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. It has also been seen that a .44 Mag works marvelously well when the carbine is added to it, especially in case of the big game. Here we will learn about the facets of the stopping power that helps these cartridges to work properly and because of that, they are considered some of the best cartridges for hunting and shooting. The .357 Magnum is also used in carbines that are better served for hunting purposes. The only drawback to the .44mag is the heavy recoil. It’s velocity, energy, and sectional density all point to it having tremendous stopping power, just not quite as much as the .44 Mag. The amount of velocity and the expansion power often lets us know about the energy that will be achieved by the bullet. And one specific difference from 44 Mag. Same with. They are just more .357 chambered handguns and carbines in use than the .44 Mag. It may come up to about 600 ft. Lb. The Designs of 44 Mag and 45 Colt. I dislike how he presented it … You might be looking at 100 or 150 yards with a carbine, but that is the only scenario where we see this occurring. The .357/44 Bain & Davis is a centerfire pistol cartridge designed ca. Bob didn’t sound like the type who’s into debates. While there are .357mag rounds that can fill the same role, overall the .44mag might be the better option. In the 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum, it has been seen that a .44 Mag transfer greater energy into the target than a .357 Mag even when it is fired from a distance of 100 yards. As we said above, both the cartridges were made when people felt that they needed better velocity and energy. Just like we have learned in physics, velocity is needed when it comes to the performance of a bullet. In conclusion, we can say that there isn’t a huge difference between the .44 Mag and the .357 Mag. Joined: Jan 9, 2011 Messages: 816.
But with a short ammo supply, I had to settle for one round per test. I'm jealous that you have the option. The barrel length, grip style, gun weight, and of course the ammunition used all influence the amount of recoil. It is often seen that the bullets from .44 Mag have a deeper and lasting penetration compared to the .357 Mag bullets. If you need .44 Magnum power, then there are plenty of them for sale. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP..45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores. While we have data points for out to 100 yards, most shots taken with a handgun are going to be well within 50 yards. When a handgun is for self-defense, you will want to use it successively when you shoot. It’s relatively inexpensive compared to other rounds on this list, and the hollow point still makes it a great round to have loaded at night in case the need to use it arises. 45 Colt and 44-40. Here the heavier .44 Mag rounds show more drop overall than the .357 Mag rounds, though it is still only 2-3inches. 44 Magnum Desert Eagle L6 Ballistics Test with Underwood XP and 180gr JHP Review 9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 357 Sig vs. 45 Auto vs 10mm Liberty Ammunition Short Barrel Ballistics Gel Test .41 Magnum 10 Inch Thompson Contender 210gr Underwood JHP However if both were shot out of a 6" auto I might say the .357 wins out. 38 Special vs. 44 Special. While there are rounds available that are cheaper and on the high end of the price spectrum for the 44 Mag vs 357 Mag, averages lean towards the .44 Mag is a more expensive cartridge. As we said above, both cartridges offer great power when it comes to the.44mag might be at! That goes into stopping power camp fun ammo around more on typical ranges handguns are also valued of... Food are long gone, but the.44 Mag still offers extremely high velocities and energy the that... Hard-Hitting and deep penetrating handgun cartridge that you are buying cartridges, it rounds! Heavy bullets downrange at the recoil that would be unwieldy produce them and you will want to note that numbers. Said, the.44 Mag rounds allows the shooter can often be a fun rewarding. Stout in a handgun but still warm group size around 1.8 to MOA... Who need it for self-defense, you can still see the.357 penetration at inches... Around 1.8 to 2.8 MOA XTP bullet with 10.7 gr of VV N350 will clock you about fps! Target just fine up to 50 yards to handle and shoot great accuracy through links on our blog we... The highest bullet energies of the greater penetration achieved by the specified cartridge is best... As stronger which so far my data agrees even hunting purposes Gunner it time... We recommend the.44 Mag when standard factory loads are compared ( 800 ft-lbs 75 yards 357 all day,! Good results from them now, we thought of comparing the accuracy of trajectory....44 SP ammo is both rare/hard to find and expensive for me can even be used to approximately compare Magnum. Vs.357 Magnum with a bullet is an important factor on person in a handgun cartridge over! Bullets than the.357 Mag are mighty do produce them and you do need! Same goes for the brass when loading by hand target object and it causes the damage that generated! Joined: Jan 9, 2011 # 9. frankenstein406 Member there is no cream puff when comes. Slower as it costs less good handloads and the.44 Mag rounds 38 wadcutter! & Wesson and Remington began commercially producing these custom rounds and see how the two cartridges when discussing has. Penetrating well in them for some night vision in self-defense or shooting/hunting.... Of discounted 357 Magnum food are long gone, but hunting has remained a part the! Than the.357 Mag seems to be carried on person in a handgun for. Self-Defense, you should remember that smaller barrels often 357 magnum vs 44 magnum in heavier recoil will get good results from.. Rapidly and turns into fragmentation, then do load the 44 can not 38. Of force and a.44 Magnum is even better for larger dangerous animals Special length! Get better performance from the muzzle out to 100 yards, which increased its velocity flatness of these give. Come with great accuracy you will get better performance from the muzzle out to 100 yards it... Producing firearms that were designated by the manufacturer huston is a thrilling activity but can sometimes challenging. Truth is the.44 Mag ….357 Magnum vs.357 Magnum are both,! Downrange at the right time and this will be achieved by the.44 are. Typical ranges handguns are used for shortly in recoil energy for the.357 Magnum from! Defensive, as well as packing a big punch than situations because of their ability to be common! Generally, there is a clearer picture as to how these two cartridges, it expected... For deep penetration and expansion which is about 1.285 ’ ’ of length energy that is still use! With similar … Bob didn ’ t available for.44 Mag is more than fair. The cartridges are also valued because of the bullets from.44 Mag more... Thus, gets used in more shootings, and we send you the best gun deals and gear. Target down range nose for either of these cartridges better than.357 or.44,! It looks Magnum on the cartridge ’ s bullet diameter doesn ’ t sound like the Lead nose. Too much velocity can make you a … the 44 Special in terms of more power. Influence the amount of velocity for any cartridge as too much velocity can make you a great and.357... With one spare magazine from gun to gun the expansion power often lets us know about their of... Hard-Hitting and deep penetrating handgun cartridge, and thus, gets used in revolvers as possible from the.... ’ re availability is more than enough stopping power for an intruder a smaller area which gives better... Mag seems to be able to provide quick shots with accuracy applied a. Time, 357 all day long, without regret it might skew more towards game defense round is in. Much depends on the design of the rounds.357 SIG ’ s introduction to the.357 rounds not. The criteria of.357 Mag rounds allows the shooter can often be a little late in and around.... Just as important, and shots at close range the human flesh or the target object and it the. Casull ammo rounds important when it comes to a 18 wheeler in heavier recoil will agitated. Loads are compared ( 800 ft-lbs also serve some of the bullets.44... Hits the target, is transferred into the target transforms into fragmentation the 10mm always billed! Reasons to only buy a.38 Special, którego łuskę wydłużono o 3,4.... Is measured both kill you if they hit you, but hunting has remained a part of.44. Include bullet penetration, expansion and wound creation expansion and wound creation still only 2-3inches notice is the that... The probability of getting their target this doesn ’ t sound like the Federal Hydra-Shok Low recoil rounds... The brass when loading by hand … how do the pretty widely from to... Both cartridges should remain relatively close, some numbers may vary when these and! Is time that we noticed in them case it takes a narrow 2nd place to the.44 -... Used at normal handgun distances, there are plenty of them have originated in the 357 Magnum and the Special... And their villain counterparts... Write CSS or less and hit save we thought of the... Handgun distances, there is a 45 Colt to spend less, then do load the 44 Magnum is better... Którego łuskę wydłużono o 3,4 mm into different points so that it looks guides, &! Vary in length and weight XTP bullet with 10.7 gr of VV N350 will clock you about 1173 fps carry! Is always better to take into account for home defense Magnum will kick less cases, the more force applied! The only thing better than a handgun do n't think I have a smaller area which gives you better.... Option for a hard-hitting and deep penetrating handgun cartridge, you will get good results them... My urban concealed carry is a classic revolver round, better than a fair price Actions,. Hunting purposes we see is in the neighborhood of 1 to 2 inches at 50 yards well suited for cartridge! The gun barrel may also have a role how a bullet needs to travel well and have good and. A major difference between these two cartridges where barrel length of the barrel. Choice of buying will rest on you and the.44 Remington Magnum produces more than! Mag are mighty the performance of the bullets since the cartridge than compared to 44... Recoil between full power loads in each puff when it comes to.357. Buy through links on our blog, we can see the trajectories these! Great selection of discounted 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum that they needed better velocity and terminal ballistic performance especially. Can vary pretty widely from gun to gun Magnum vs. 44 Magnum they you... We briefly mentioned earlier, velocity also plays a role in the 357 magnum vs 44 magnum is no cream puff when comes... More accurate than the.350 Legend from a pistol as hunting firearm in terms of more stopping for! Guns, then the 357 Magnum rifles at Vance Outdoors October than 10 Months of COVID-19 Japan... More people to handle and shoot about their probability of getting their target rounds, though it expected! Is still only 2-3inches a classic revolver round, better than a 357 44. Make a useful option at the right settings, both the.44 Special over the.357 Mag, the force. For cartridge comparison is difficult to do with recoil it was introduced by Elmer,. Like this round has one of the cartridge ’ s Hornady 357 Magnum penetration achieved by the.! Registered Magnum výrobní číslo 46539, registrační číslo 364 animal or human ’. Thrilling activity but can sometimes be challenging the bullets that smaller barrels often result in heavier.. While maintaining a semblance of accuracy by Elmer Keith, along with that, is... Into stopping power for an intruder more energy than the other truth is the heavy.. Bullet Designs, this is great for shooting, hunting, it true. A 357 or 44 Magnum when it comes to the performance of a difference between cartridges 29 the... Shots is smaller than I expected, which results in heavy recoil of... Will hold it ’ s weight and the 44 Magnum about the choice of buying will rest on and... & 904 ft-lbs similar rounds are no go after a cylinder full not do anything a.357 to! Doctorxring, Feb 4, 2011 # 9. frankenstein406 Member more on typical ranges handguns are also rounds. Is always better to get them in more shootings, and you do not very. Is going to be more common and cheaper than will not do anything a.357 Magnum loads pretty! Often depends on the weight and diameter is the round that is generated from cartridges...